2009 DRAFT REVIEW

By Tinkers, Evers & Chance Inc.

 

 

 

 

DOUGS' DESTROYERS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS::

J Papelbon, A Ramirez, B Roberts 

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK: 

L Berkman:

STARTERS - 

Division (4), League (8)

BENCH - 

Division (3), League (4)

PITCHING - 

Division (3), League (5)

BULLPEN - 

Division (3), League (7)

OUTLOOK - The Destroyers started with a good base with their franchise players. The starters may be a little Astro heavy but still a decent group. The bench is anchored by G Anderson & M Reynolds. The flyer taken on G Sheffield may come back to haunt the Destroyers. Starting pitching is strong but the picks of Zito and Backe are high risk choices. 

PROJECTED FINISH - 87-75, 2nd Slammer Division

 

 

MITCHELLVILLE MAULERS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

B Lidge, A Soriano, D Ortiz

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

I Kinsler

STARTERS - 

Division (6), League (12)

BENCH - 

Division (1), League (1)

PITCHING - 

Division (4), League (8)

BULLPEN - 

Division (6), League (12)

OUTLOOK - The Maulers have a new name, a new look but the outlook looks to be a repeat of 2008. The franchise choice of D Ortiz might hurt the Maulers as he seems to be declining quickly. The reserves are stronger than the starters for the Maulers. Reserves Francoeur and Lind will be in the starting line-up sooner rather than later. Weak links in Tulowitzski & Iannetta do not have serviceable back-ups. The pitching is OK with Hernandez, Volquez & Lidge but the bullpen is weak with unknown starters and a Pirate closer.
PROJECTED FINISH - 80-82, 6th Slugger Division

 

 

 

SWELL GUYS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

A Rodriguez, V Guerrero, C Utley

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

Ca Lee

STARTERS - 

Division (5), League (10)

BENCH - 

Division (3), League (6)

PITCHING - 

Division (3), League (6)

BULLPEN - 

Division (2), League (2)

OUTLOOK - Coming off a sub-par 2008 season the Swell Guys seem to have drafted well enough to start moving back up the ladder. With the franchise player A Rodriguez the Swell Guys have a better bench than starting line-up. Mixing youth and experience the Swell Guys might feel the wrath of declining seasons from V Guerrero & B Abreu. They also may have found a diamond in the rough with N Cruz. Pitching looks to be strong with the only questions being A Cook & A Sanchez. Hamels, Harden & Myers will keep the Swell Guys in the race. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 88-74, 3rd Slugger Division

 

 

 

GRIMES BOMBERS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

J Reyes, G Sizemore, R Braun

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

C Granderson

STARTERS - 

Division (3), League (7)

BENCH - 

Division (2), League (3)

PITCHING - 

Division (5), League (9)

BULLPEN - 

Division (4), League (8)

OUTLOOK - Owner Sauer vowed to go with youth in 2009. They certainly did that picking sleepers Davis, Votto & Bruce in the starting line-up. The reserves are bolstered by Swisher & Scott. The pitching is not as strong as the hitting with Wellemeyer, Price & Hanson being the weaker links and knowingly drafting injured Duchscherer. Soria gives the Bomber one of the best closers in the league. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 85-77, 3rd Slammer Division

 

 

 

BUTTUGLIES

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

T Lincecum, CC Sabathia, M Kemp

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

C Crawford

STARTERS - 

Division (6), League (11)

BENCH - 

Division (6), League (12)

PITCHING - 

Division (1), League (3)

BULLPEN - 

Division (2), League (4) 

OUTLOOK - Starting and finishing with pitching the Buttuglies have one of the strongest pitching staffs in the league. Lincecum, Sabathina, Grienke along with Rivera are locks to carry the Buttuglies offense. The selections of Renteria & Crisp will hamper some of the scoring while the reserve choices of Wieters, Dukes and the position less Teahen will slow down the offense. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 79-83, 5th Slammer Division

 

 

SPTINGFIELD STOGIES

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

A Gonzalez, I Suzuki, J Rollins

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

D Pefroia

STARTERS - 

Division (2), League (4)

BENCH - 

Division (4), League (8)

PITCHING - 

Division (6), League (10)

BULLPEN - 

Division (6), League (11)

OUTLOOK - The Stogies made a draft day whopper of a deal in securing A Pujols for his 3 franchise players. It looks like Pujols is going to need help carrying this team. The drafting of Pedroia, Peralta & Ordonez will keep the offense rolling but if they need to get into the bench it might cause some problems. The drafting of F Tatis ensures a free agent transaction while youngsters Morales, Willingham & Beckham could hamper the offense. Pitching looks to be slight coming from an Owner which proudly exclaimed "Look at my staff!" in a previous draft. D Haren is the only strong pitcher in the group followed by the aging Moyer. Carpenter, Broxton, Perez, Snell and Wakefield are all risky picks. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 81-81, 4th Slammer Division

 

 

SOUTHSIDE EXCALIBUR

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

M Ramirez, C Beltran, M Cabrera

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

F Rodriguez

STARTERS - 

Division (1), League (1)

BENCH - 

Division (6), League (10)

PITCHING - 

Division (1), League (1)

BULLPEN - 

Division (1), League (1)

OUTLOOK - The offense is strong with the franchise players along with Hudson, Youkilis, Werth, Ibanez & Jacobs. The choice of Giambi was a risk for power numbers. The bench is questionable. Ross, Moss and Burriss have potential but it may not be in the 2009 season which may cause a problem if the Excalibur have injury problems. The pitching staff comes in #1 based on the numbers but looking at it S Lewis is a horrible choice as a 5th starter and if Dempster, Lee, Meche & Buehrle start slow the Excalibur might have to depend on Lannan and Braden. Not awe inspiring but still overall a top staff based on numbers. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 95-67, 1st Slugger Division

 

 

ROCKFORD MAFIA

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

E Longoria, J Hamilton, M Holliday

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

C Quentin

STARTERS - 

Division (5), League (9)

BENCH - 

Division (5), League (11)

PITCHING - 

Division (4), League (7)

BULLPEN - 

Division (5), League (10)

OUTLOOK - The Mafia surpassed the projections in 2008 and ended the season 2nd in the Slammer Division. They will need to again surpass projections in 2009. The franchise players are talented but Longoria & Hamilton may experience sophomore slumps. Starting hitting has minimal pop and might suffer setbacks if Bradley is the Bradley we all know. Fielder, Ankiel and Quentin have some pop. The reserves are made up mostly of Cardinal/Whitesox players and unproven rookies in Andrus & Getz. The pitching staff is enough to get them some wins and can become a surprise staff if Johnson, Carmona & Danks can live up to their potential. Scherzer, Reyes and Marmol look like picks trying to catch lightening in a bottle like the 2008 pick of Longoria & Hamilton. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 76-86, 6th Slammer Division

 

 

AMAZIN' WOMBATS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

H Ramirez, R Howard, R Martin

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

B Phillips

STARTERS - 

Division (4), League (6)

BENCH - 

Division (5), League (9)

PITCHING - 

Division (6), League (12)

BULLPEN - 

Division (4), League (5)

OUTLOOK - The franchise players are top flight especially Ramirez & Martin based on the lack of stars at those positions. The starting line-up is scattered with veteran leadership from the "Flyin' Hawaiian" Victorino,  DeRosa, Dye & Konerko. The reserves are just that, reserves. Scutaro, Lowrie, Barajas & Milledge will all be struggling with playing time and thus might cost the Wombats if their starters go down or slump. Pitching is also a little weak. After Nolasco, Jurrjens & Lilly the Wombats are hoping for either bounce back years (Harang, Bush, Millwood) or breakout years (Billingsley, Sanchez). The Wombats still use their team concept of carrying 3 closers. Maybe they are hoping for a trade. Street, Qualls & Gonzalez could all have trouble getting saves. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 81-81, 5th Slugger Division

 

 

WOOD COUNTY GAMBLERS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

N McLouth, B Webb, J Shields

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

N Markakis

STARTERS - 

Division (3), League (5)

BENCH - 

Division (4), League (7)

PITCHING - 

Division (2), League (2)

BULLPEN - 

Division (3), League (5)

OUTLOOK - After choosing players who still look strong in Delgado, Uggla, Young & Markakis the Gamblers looked to be trying to find a diamond in the rough with Choo, Spilbourghs and Sandoval. Drafting the declining Lowell & Dunn was a risk. The reserves also are littered with youth in Dickerson, Span, Teagarden and Bonifacio. The pitching is strong behind Webb, Zambrano, Floyd and Shields. Wilson might be a risk depending on save opps in SF. The bullpen has potential but Harrison, Baek & Motte are high risk, high reward players at this time. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 88-74, 2nd Slugger Division

 

 

OMAHA ASSASSINS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

D Wright, M Teixeira, J Morneau

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

A Rios

STARTERS - 

Division (3), League (3)

BENCH - 

Division (2), League (5)

PITCHING - 

Division (5), League (11)

BULLPEN - 

Division (5), League (9)

OUTLOOK - Franchise players are some of the best the league has to offer. Hitting does not seem to be a question for the Assassins. Ethier, Rios, Ellsbury, Hawpe & Loney are proven and not looking to decline soon. The bench seems to be a little stronger with 2B Sanchez & Weeks being a possible better option than A Cabrera. Francisco and Morgan have good upside. The pitching staff has Beckett, Pettitte, Sonnanstine and Jenks for stability while Chamberlain and Vazquez are still question marks. The bullpen has injuries and unknowns with Escobar starting on the D.L. and Uehara, Marshall and Fuentes being very unproven.
PROJECTED FINISH - 82-80, 4th Slugger Division

 

BALFORS

FRANCHISE PLAYERS - 

A Pujols, J Bay, J Santana

1ST ROUND DRAFT PICK - 

R Ludwick

STARTERS - 

Division (1), League (2)

BENCH - 

Division (1), League (2)

PITCHING - 

Division (2), League (4)

BULLPEN - 

Division (1), League (3)

OUTLOOK - Where do you go from the top? Can you say further up? Well we will see if that happens but starting off the draft with 5 franchise players is not a bad way to start. The awe inspiring trade of A Pujols for I Suzuki, J Rollins and A Gonzalez started the draft off with the championship being handed to the Balfors again. Owner Keady has proven he can draft too. The Balfors are strong with their offense that also includes C Jones, J Thome, B Giles and R Ludwick. Suzuki leads the reserves along with Garko, Gomez, Inge and Kubel. No real fall from the starters to the reserves. Pitching will always be strong when you can start with J Santana and then add Halladay, Garland & Valverde. The bullpen is not as strong with injured Santana but has bright futures in Baker, Jimenez & Cordero. The numbers say the Balfors will again win the division but anything can happen. 
PROJECTED FINISH - 94-68, 1st Slammer Division

 

 

PROJECTED 2009 STANDINGS

POSITION TEAM RECORD
1 SOUTHSIDE EXCALIBUR 95-67
2 WOOD COUNTY GAMBLERS 88-74
3 SWELL GUYS 88-74
4 OMAHA ASSASSINS 82-80
5 AMAZIN' WOMBATS 81-81
6 MITCHELLVILLE MAULERS 80-82
     
1 BALFORS 94-68
2 DOUG'S DESTROYERS 87-75
3 GRIMES BOMBERS 85-77
4 SPRINGFIELD STOGIES 81-81
5 BUTTUGLIES 79-83
6 ROCKFORD MAFIA 76-86
 

Tinkers, Evers & Chance Inc Notes:

The rankings and projected finishes are based upon the pre-draft rankings and points projected by this company. These points did not take into consideration extended injuries and slumps. These are based on projections assuming the players are playing at full health and for a full season. The projected finishes also used a complicated system based upon the points and the average of points scored by previous league winners. All projections are opinions of this company and are subject to outside questioning and ridicule. We would expect nothing less.

If you have questions or comments regarding this review please forward them to the league commissioner. 

Thanks,                                                       

T/E/C INC