1997:
Charles Woodson, CB, Michigan
1995:
Eddie George, TB, Ohio State
1991:
Desmond Howard, WR, Michigan
1975:
Archie Griffin, TB, Ohio State
1974: Archie Griffin, TB, Ohio State
1955: 'Hopalong' Cassidy, Back, Ohio State
1950: Vic Janowicz, Back, Ohio State
1944: Les Horvath, Back, Ohio State
1940:
Tom Harmon, Back, Michigan