20th Century Replay Baseball League

Chicago National League Ballclub Page


There was no Wrigley field and no ivy back in 1901, the season with which we began our replay league. There weren't even any Cubs! They were the Chicago Orphans and they played in West Side Park.

Click here to see pictures of West Side Park from the early 1900's. It takes a while for it to load.


1901
1901 was our first season and I had 11th pick in a serpentine draft. I took Fred Clarke first and Topsy Hartsel second hoping I could get some steals in the pitching area. Clarke and Hartsel did great but if you look at the stas, you can see that my pitchers did not quite live up to expectations and I finished 20 games out.

Season Stats


1902
After a disappointing performance by my pitching staff in '01, I began to realize that a good defense was very important in order for pitchers to do well in Strato. This draft was a weak one. I selected John Gochnauer, the best defensive ss available, with my first pick. We improved by 6 games, but I was still frustrated by my pitching. I gave up ownership of the team in frustration.

Season Stats


1903
Key acquisitions by the team this year were John Titus, Doc Gessler, Nick Altrock, and Jake Weimer. However, their record fell by 11 games down to only 68 wins.

Season Stats


1904
I got back in the league because a franchise had become available. It was the Cubs!!! My first pick was Fred Odwell. Nick Altrock, Ed Killian, Jack Taylor, and Jake Weimer made a formidable foursome on the mound as Taylor won 35 and Altrock and Weimer each won 26. A late season acquisition of Ginger Beaumont (for Doc Gessler and my second pick in '05) put me over the top to win the NL pennant. Beaumont hit .384 for me with 36 RBI's in 44 games.

The World Series did not go as well as we fell to the Highlanders 4 games to 2. The key to our loss was season ERA leader Jake Weimer throwing 18 innings and posting an ERA of 6.00.

Season Stats


WS Stats


1905
Having the last pick each round as well as trading away my second pick was more devastating than I thought it would be. I chose Ed Cicotte first with the idea of making him a franchise player and building my team around him, but ended up cutting him after the season when I realized he didn't play in "06 and "07. Billy Gilbert and Harry Arndt helped, but we fell back into the second division. I added Addie Joss just after the halfway point.

Season Stats

 

1906

I got the eighth pick overall in the lottery, but traded up to get pick #2. I chose Eddie Collins with that pick and plan to start building around him, but he doesn't start to produce HOF numbers until 1909.

Addie Joss pitches well, but ERA is 0.80 above real life. New pick Carlos Moran disappoints in the lead off role. We drop to 98 losses.

Season Stats

 

1907

I was able to acquire future HOFer Tris Speaker with my first pick. Also returned former favorite Wild Bill Donovan to the fold. Donovan had an All Star season (19-13 with a 1.82 ERA) while Joss and Frank Laporte continued to play well below their stats. Lost a franchise high 106 games.

Season Stats

 

1908

I chose Ed Summers with my first pick and then traded the often disappointing Joss to get Joe Jackson. Got an awful contract roll for Jackson and will have to give him a new contract before he produces if I want to keep him.

Two fine selections in the lower rounds of Chief Wilson and Larry Gardner give me a formidable nucleus to build around.

Season in progress



1