Home Depot
 Lumber
 Off Grade
 Lawsuit
 Murphy
 Destruction
 Opposed
 Consumer
 Unethical
 Statements
 Bulletin Board

Do You Want Your Own Bulletin Board?

 OFF GRADE LUMBER

In March 1993, I had just moved to West Palm Beach, FL and noticed a serious problem with the lumber quality that I hadn't noticed in Orlando, FL.  After checking all the Home Depot stores in Palm Beach County I discovered all their stores were selling below grade #2 White Pine boards although they were stamped and sold as #2 pine.  As we all know, when Home Depot comes to town their main objective is to run the competition out of business, so local lumberyards are usually the first to go.  Since my husband and I needed pine lumber for our furniture business we were forced to purchase from Home Depot more and more as lumber yards closed.

When shopping at all of the Home Depot stores in Palm Beach County netted us zero pine boards, something was wrong.  I contacted Ben Hill (Home Depot's 1-800 customer service number) which resulted in a phone call from Home Depot's lumber buyer, Steve Conwell, a letter from Bruce Berg, Home Depotīs President, Southeast Division, and a phone call to Home Depotīs lumber supplier Ted Ellis, Vice President at Idaho Timber.  Obviously I hit a nerve.  I had accused Home Depot of deliberately sending below grade lumber to their stores in Palm Beach County.  On several occasions I watched employees put lumber into the racks and it had the appearance of old, dirty lumber.  A meeting with lumber buyer Steve Conwell at store #225 in West Palm Beach confirmed there was a "problem" with the lumber.  While Mr. Conwell was working on the "problem" he decided he was going to ship lumber to the store with my name on it and store it in their overhead rack so that it wouldn't be sold to any other customers, at no cost to me and I could purchase the boards as needed on their dime.  He said he would instruct Idaho Timber to put together units of 1"X12"X6' Ponderosa Pine boards to which they assigned the name Thomas Grade Lumber.  This meant the best of what Idaho Timber had at their five mills was going to me, which was #1 and select grade lumber.  Even though these boards retail for over $20 a piece Home Depot was only going to charge me the same price they charged for #2 pine which was about $8.00 per board.  There was a lot of problems getting this grade lumber to me during the 2― years this Program was in existence. A lot of lumber was off grade due to milling imperfections, high moisture content, and sometimes our lumber just disappeared in transit from Idaho to Florida.  This led to many phone calls to Home Depot and Idaho Timber, which eventually gave us full knowledge of Home Depotīs lumber operation.  We learned that Home Depot does in fact separate their lumber and assigns different numbers and names to direct the shipments to certain stores across the United States.  For example a #2 Ponderosa Pine board is separated according to quality into 1 of 4 bins at Idaho Timber's Mill. (I was told by an employee that it was now up to 10 bins).  Idaho Timber called their best #2 pine "metro" and that went to high competitive market areas and Atlanta.  The other lumber was shipped across the United States accordingly.  Along with Florida, they called New Mexico and Texas their dumping grounds for bad lumber.

 

Click Here to Go Back To Lumber

Copyright Đ GT 1998 All Rights Reserved

Please Note That All References Made In This Website To #1 Pine Boards and #2 Pine Boards Are Called 1 COMMON and 2 COMMON Under Lumber Grading Rules.

email22