Religious Reflections

Learn More About:  Mother Mary Maddalena
 St. Francis  

Mother Mary Magdalen Bentivoglio
Mother Mary Maddalena Bentivoglio
-Sister M. Cecilia Switalski, OSC

This is our story, the story of Mother Mary Maddalena, the foundress of the Poor Clares in America. This is a true story beginning with the knight errant of Assisi.

From First Celano we see God's will clarified for Francis when he heard from the Gospel and in the Church of the Portiuncula, "Take nothing for the journey; neither walking staff nor traveling bag; no bread, no money, no one is to have two coats." (Luke 9:3). Francis, on hearing this, cried out exultantly, "This is what I wish, this is what I seek, this is what I long to do with all my heart."

In the Rule of 1221, Chapter 17, Francis writes, "We must be firmly convinced that we have nothing of our own, except our vices and our sin."

In Luke 9:23 we read, "Whoever wishes to be my follower must deny his very self, take up his cross each day and follow in my steps."

In Matthew 9:21 we read, "If you seek perfection, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor. You will then have treasure in heaven. Afterward, come back and follow me."

Pondering these passages, it is clear that Francis and his early followers desired to have no rights, were to make no demands, were to be radically dependent upon a loving and provident Father; to believe that all one experiences, God draws into his plan, that is, to purify, form, and bring into the full image of his Son. Our only possessions are our sins.

We see this radical dependency upon God replicated in Clare as she held the Blessed Sacrament before the Saracen invaders.


Mother Mary Magdalen Bentivoglio
Foundress of Poor Clares in America
 
 
 
Mother Mary Constance Bentivoglio Scarcely had Mother Maddalena (sometimes referred to as Mother Magdalen) and Mother Constanza (sometimes referred to as Mother Constance) set foot on American soil when they were asked to take up his cross. Following Father Paolino's advice, the Friar who had been officially appointed as the spiritual director and convent chaplain of the Minnesota Foundation, they broke the news to Mother Ignatius Hayes, telling her that certain obstacles had arisen which, for the present, compelled them to remain where they were until further orders from Rome would arrive. Mother Maddalena writes: "Poor Mother Ignatius felt the refusal very much; yet having no binding claim upon us, she resigned herself to the inevitable and departed from us with sorrows and grief in her heart." For the Poor Clares there now began a long, Via Dolorosa; for Mother Mary Ignatius it was another shattered hope as she walked her "Way of the Cross." (Mother Mary Ignatius was the Foundress of the Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls, Minnesota.)

Mother Mary Constance Bentivoglio
Co-Foundress with Mother Mary Magdalen
 
 
A letter from Fra Bernardino, Minister General, dated November 9, 1875, clearly indicated the many trials to which Mother Mary Maddalena and Mother Constanza had already been subjected. The following is the letter, a literal translation:
 
                                Rome, Aracoeli, November 9, 1875
 
My Dearest and venerable daughters in Jesus Christ,

        I have not written to you earlier because I did not know what to decide. I awaited your arrival at the destined place and the description which you were to have given me of it. However, I have never forgotten you, my good daughters; I have always prayed for you. Many times each day I have sent you the paternal blessing and several times I have offered the Holy Sacrifice for you expressly because I have felt within me some sort of anxiety.

        Now I have received your letters with one from Father Paulino and all of them tell me things are most difficult--that the foundation of Minnesota is impossible. Well, then, remain there until the Most Reverend Custos Carlo da Nazzano, to whom I have recommended you, will decide where it might be convenient to move you; and in silence, in prayer, in sacrifice await for the Lord to manifest his most holy will. If the Lord wills that in the United States Saint Clare should have a monastery, be it in New York or some other city, you will thank the Lord that he deigned to choose you as an instrument of his glory and of the glory of Saint Clare; on the other hand, if in America it is impossible to conclude anything and you will return to Europe, then be happy with your humiliation before men. Certainly Jesus will take everything into account on your behalf and with him will remain entire the merit of your sacrifice as was that of Abraham.

        I, for my part, will likewise share in humiliation and will voluntarily offer it to the Lord who knows the rightness of my intentions. Certainly both I and you believed we were doing the will of God. But if now God lets us know that his will is otherwise we will be equally content. You must pray, pray, so that the Devine Will be fulfilled and nothing else. After I will have received new and more specific information which I have asked for and after I will have received orders from the Holy Father, I will give you the definitive decision.

        Good-bye, my good daughters, strive on generously, patiently and lovingly, committing yourself to the Sacred Heart of Jesus and you will find it in all comfort and consolation. Concerning me, please never doubt, I pray for you and I bless you always.

                                               Your most affectionate father in Christ,
                                               Fra Bernardino, Minister General

 
 
 
The next letter which Fra Bernardino wrote to Mother Maddalena is dated May 23, 1876. The following is part of that letter:

          "Now, having come to Florence, for only four days, I have brought along all of your letters and here, scarcely having arrived, I put aside every other thing and I make ready to answer you. And this entails nothing other than saying that in spite of my painful silence, painful for you and for me, I have never ceased blessing you and praying and offering many times for you the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass and that I have for you fatherly concern which has but one direction to tell you that I suffer along with you, with all my heart, all of your difficulties which test your patience and generosity and that I thank Jesus for them that he grants them to you.

        However, since this point naturally forms the principal object of your desires, namely, to know that my decision relative to going ahead with or stopping the proposed foundation and if "no" where and under what conditions are things to be done. Well, I still do not feel the courage to make a definite answer. To tell you, "Turn back to your Monastery of San Lorenzo," would be a bit too painful for mine and your self-esteem. On the other hand, and in the long run, it would be the easiest solution. The enemies would murmur a bit against me and against you, but then the whole affair would be finished. But, would that then be the will of God? I still do not have enough reasons to convince me of this. On the contrary, your generosity in leaving Europe, your patience and prolonged uncertainty, and in the present difficulties, the opinion of most worthy persons who have spoken of you and to you, the offers of help tendered to you, the several postulants you have had come to you--all these things lead me to hold that God wills this foundation. Consequently, basing myself upon this confidence that this be the will of God my advice is:

  1. That the foundation should be made in the United States of America and not elsewhere.
  2. That it should consist of true Poor Clares without schools and with a perfect cloister.
  3. That the idea of Minnesota with that of Mother Ignatius be definitively abandoned.
  4. That a foundation be procured primarily in New York, and, if this does not succeed, then in Cincinnati, or Philadelphia.
  5.         Gradually, the Lord, I hope, will let us know his will more specifically and we will be happy to fulfill it, whatever it might be."

 
 
 
From these letters it is clear that our Mothers were having the experience of being pilgrims and strangers in this world and to realize that they did not have here below a permanent city. Father Bernardino tells them that they will be tranquil and content if they establish themselves in the adorable Sacred Heart of Jesus, thus sharing in its pains as well as in its loves, and striving to draw from it to themselves, its sublime virtues, especially humility, patience, sweetness, the knowledge of how to sympathize with and sustain one another.

These letters likewise reflect their courage, generosity, waiting in uncertainty to know God's will, their mendicancy, their radical dependency upon God as they waited for months to hear from the Minister General.

After unsuccessful attempts in New York, Philadelphia, New Orleans and Cleveland they finally came to Omaha on August 15, 1878. Bishop O'Conner received them warmly but frankly told them that he was unable to do anything for them but John Creighton or others would be able to help them.

 
 
Count John Creighton When Mr. Creighton met Mother Maddalena he was so impressed that, on September 2, he purchased six and one-half acres between Hamilton and Caldwell Streets as the site for a monastery. At first they had a small house as a temporary residence. Since the house was too small for five women Mr. Creighton rented a slightly larger house on Burt Street where they moved on November 5.

Count John Creighton

 
 
Lucretia Creighton On Saturday, June 5, 1880, at 8:00 p.m., a fearful storm arose which leveled the convent which was under construction. Not until Monday did Mother Maddalena and two of the Sisters go over to Eden Hill. Their eyes beheld a sickening mass of ruins. "We mourned over our beloved Jerusalem." She thought that the repeated destruction of the building might be an indication of God's will that they were not to stay in Omaha. The Minister General hastened to assure her; Father Peter whom she had consulted, did the same: "No, Reverend Mother, stay where you are. God will take care of you." God took over and it was God's work. Even as Francis had to recognize that his Order was out of control, he had to be convinced that it was really God's Order.
Lucretia Creighton
Wife of John Creighton

 
 
After a period of time there were false accusations made against the two Bentivoglio sisters; these accusations were made chiefly by two extern Sisters from their own community. They were accused of having a great degree of irregular personal conduct, alcohol problems, mismanagement of the finances and acting without proper regard for the hierarchical procedures.

On September 9, 1888, the two delegates, Father Boniface, OFM, and Father Schaffel, SJ, Vicar General, with the Reverend P. McCarthy as secretary, came to the monastery and presented their credentials. Mother Maddalena and Constanza were informed that for the time of the visitation (which was being conducted in their monastery) they would have to betake themselves to the convent of the Sisters of Mercy on 13th street, and that they would have to leave the next morning. If their accusers prevail again, these hours will be their last in this monastery which was cemented, brick by brick, with ten hard years of their life. Mother Maddalena wrote into the Chronicle: "We make ourselves ready to leave home, -more yet, ready to go even to the end of the earth to make happy those Sisters whom we have received with love and care--but oh!!!"

At 8:00 the next morning, a carriage was at the entrance of the monastery to convey Mothers Maddalena and Constanza to the Sisters of Mercy. Fathers Boniface and McCarthy accompanied them. Years later, when asked about the impression which he had received of Mother Maddalena in those days, Father Boniface stated: "I hereby -- on my priestly word -- testify that the behavior of Reverend Mother Maddalena (during the ride and after reaching the monastery of her temporary banishment) was the most exemplary, edifying, and saintly that could ever have been expected from a virtuous creature, taking into due consideration the awful, trying, humiliating and heart-rending ordeal she went through. While I was riding with her in the carriage, she uttered not a word against her two young accusers, not a word of reproach or complaint against her unfair ecclesiastical superior. Though extremely affected by the severe measure, she allowed her human nature a few furtive sobs and tears, still not a word dropped from her lips which was not prompted by a humble resignation to God's will and by an unlimited confidence in his assistance as to the final result of the investigation in her behalf. Having thus paid a little tribute to the human frailty, she calmly became cheerful and confident in the outcome of her cause as only a guiltless soul can be. She was even the consoling and encouraging angel of her sister."

Constanza soon regained her composure to the degree that she said: "Maddalena, they must thing that we are fools. We are under the most fearful accusations, yet here we are laughing." To which Maddalena replied: "I cannot help it. All my life I have asked God for crosses, and now that he has sent them, why should I not be glad?"

 
 
 
When the visitors were told that the two extern Sisters had left the monastery before the visitation was completed, a decision was made to terminate the investigation. There was evidence from the visitation that Mother Maddalena and Mother Constanza were innocent.

Great in the days of her humiliation, she was even greater in the days of her exaltation. Father Boniface testified in the statement already referred to: "When the investigation was over, and I accompanied both Mothers to their monastery, Mother Mary Maddalena was just as humble, meek, and of equable mind as a saint. Neither during the ride, nor after in the monastery, did she have either a word of self-complacency or a word of condemnation for her accusers. Thankful to God that her innocence was fully established by the long, minute, and rigorous investigation, she gave praise to him. She was not in the least exalted by the success. I can swear without the slightest hesitation that she was simply admirable for her self-possession and self-control -- equally composed in her affliction and in her enjoyment."

The answer from Rome was dated January 12, 1889. "From the examination of the facts, the depositions of the witnesses interrogated, the result is that the accusations made against the Bentivoglio sisters are not justified."

On January 31, 1889, the bishop sent his secretary-chancellor to the monastery to communicate this decision to the Servant of God and to Mother Constanza. Later the bishop himself came to the monastery. In the presence of a witness he not only expressed his regrets, he even begged pardon for the anguish that had been caused to the Servant of God and to her sister.

Poor Clare life in America continued to grow and flourish. In 1895 Mother Maddalena applied for permission to found a monastery in Evansville, Indiana. The permission was granted. The Evansville foundation was solemnly blessed by Bishop Silas Chatard on August 12, 1897. It was in this monastery that Mother Maddalena died on August 18, 1905.

Shortly after Mother Maddalena's death, steps were taken toward her eventual canonization. In 1928 the Process was inaugurated; at present the Cause for the Beatification of the Servant of God, Venerable Mother Mary Magdalen Bentivoglio, has advanced so far that all that remains to be fulfilled for its completion are the testimonies of two miracles attributed to her intercession. It is important to stress the fact that for a miracle to be attributed to the intercession of the Servant of God, no other saint may have been invoked in the particular instance for which a miracle is desired. The Beatification of the saintly abbess is greatly desired and it is ardently hoped that any persons receiving miraculous aid through her intercession will write to the abbess of the Monastery of St. Clare in Omaha, 3626 North 65 Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska 68104-3229.

The Blessing of St. Clare

May Almighty God bless you.

May he look upon you with the eyes of his mercy and give you his peace.

May he pour forth his graces on you abundantly,
and in heaven may he place you among his saints!

For more information on the life of a Poor Clare in Omaha, Nebraska
please write, telephone, fax.

You are visitor number:




Home Who We Are Who is a Poor Clare? About the Monastery Contact Information Map |

|  Daily Schedule Bulletin Board Recognitions and Awards |

St. Francis  | Mother Mary Maddalena 

A Visit From Mother Teresa Meet Our Cat, Yeller |

*** This page was last updated on:    Thursday, July 20, 2000 at 06:13 PM ***