Design Disasters

(and Bad Ideas)

This page is where I let off some steam about some of the ridiculous things I come across regularly at work. I'm talking about landcapes designed with no forethought as to what it would look like when it matured, or that someome would have to maintain the mess. They may have been "cute" when they were planted, but they've turned into monsters. I'm the one they call to "fix" them. Unfortunately, especially with commercial properties,by the time they realize what a mess they have, its gotten so out of hand, that the best solution is often to dig it up and start from scratch.
Photo: Here's an example
Photo: Another Example

(There are some nice azaleas hidden behind that elaeagnus.)

Here's a stupid idea.(Photo) Those are chinese hollies on one side and Eyonomous manhattan on the other. Each planted less than 12 inches from the sidewalk! Not only does it require frequent trimming, (yes, in this case shearing) but I bet that chinese holly is a big reason for women in these offices not to wear dresses! What were they thinking when they did this?! They obviously weren't.

Sometimes I come accross brand new plantings that I can see will be disasters when they mature. If the plants are already crowded, or growing over curbs and such, trimming can't stop the disaster. It can at best postpone it. If moving a plant or two will help, I do that, but they seldom want to pay me to redo a whole bed they just paid some incompetent to install.

Photo: Here's an example
Photo: These are crowded already, & just planted
Photo: Cute now, but these are "pfitzers"

It never ceases to amaze me that people will spend big money on a landscape without the slightest idea what any of the plants are. Then in a few years they complain when a plant does what it is supposed to!

Creeping Groundcover Nightmares

It was cute when it was planted. Some low "creeping"junipers, surrounded by a row of monkey grass. But,the juniper creeped; and the monkey grass spread. Now we have a frightful mess! Maybe that's why they call it "creeping" juniper! Next time, stick to one groundcover per bed!
Photo: groundcover nightmare
Photo: Liriope and juniper don't mix

I'd trim it if I Could Get to it!

Be sure there is access to your plants for maintenance. For example, I came upon a bed recently with several Euonymus Manhattans (a high maintennce plant) surrounded completely with Chinese Hollies.(Ouch!) Not even room for a foot anywhere! After I painfully managed to trim the manhattans, I had to pick up the trimmings by hand, piece, by piece! (You can't rake trimmings out of chinese hollies!) I would really love to have a talk with whoever designed that mess!! Think about how you will maintain your plants before you plant. Don't put high
maintenance plants in hard to reach places.

Photo: Mahatttan surrounded by chinese hollies (ouch)
Photo: Hard to get to the plants in back
Can't get to these either!: Photo

Junipers

Junipers are evergreen and they come in all sizes.That's one of the problems. I don't think most people realize that a Pfitzer juniper will easly reach 7 feet tall and 10 feet wide. I've seen them planted 2 feet apart and 1 foot from a curb. (But they don't want them to grow over the curb!) And I'm supposed to "trim" them!

They may look OK when planted, as 3 gallon size plants, but not for long. Trimming cannot "fix" such ridiculous mistakes. Junipers tend to die out in the middle anyway, but even more so when overcrowded. You can't trim them back very far without getting into the "dead zone". When overcrowded, they will attempt to thin themselves out. branches will die because they are to crowded, leaving ugly, brown pacthes.

Some landscape designers (?) get carried away and plant them every where, 2 or 3 varieties in a bed, and most of them too close together. Most junipers get much wider than tall. A sargent juniper gets only 1 foot tall but 6-8 feet wide. When spacing plants the mature width is even more important than the height. Overcrowded plants look bad, and are not healthy.

If some of these people that put them so close togther, and close to curbs and such had to try to maintain their monsters they would take more care in their designs. I doubt they care what it looks like after they get paid, or they would think about it. I hate to see so many plants that can never grow to their full potenial.

Of course junipers are far from the only victims, but they are one of the most common.

Most junipers do not age well.(especially when overcrowded.) In the 10+ years I've been landscaping I have removed many more junipers than I have planted. It is much more expensive to remove a mature one than it is to plant a young one. If you think you want to plant a juniper, make sure you know what variety you are planting, and its mature size and form.

A pfitzer juniper in a large enough space can look good for many years. Unfortunately, I rarely see them given enough room, and properly placed.

Photo: Pfitzers-cute now but watch out!
Juniper Obssesion: Photo
They had no idea how big a pfitzer gets: Photo
More about Junipers

Low growing Junipers grab on to leaves and won't let go. The toughest battle I've fought is with junipers under Magnolia trees. I have come to the conclusion that it is humanly impossible to get all of the magnolia leaves out! If you don't want leaves in your beds, don't plant junipers under trees, especially magnolias!!


If a bed looks "Full" and "tight" when it is first planted. You will have a crowded mess on your hands when it matures! You must leave room for plants to mature. Know the mature size before you plant. Plants should be spaced as far apart as the mature width. Farther, if you want space between them. If you feel there is too much empty space at first, fill in with annuals for the first year or two.

Any landscape designer who uses leatherleaf viburnums as a foundation planting is a sick, cruel, heartless person.

Photo: this will be a real mess
This probably looked "cute" when they planted it!


Bob and Mary bought a house. They went to the garden center at the neighborhood discount store. Mary sees a cute little bush in a little pot. "I want it" says Mary."what is it?" asks Bob."Gee, I don't know; but its cute and I want it, to plant under the windowsill" says Mary."OK" says Bob So they take it home and plant it under the windowsill.

Five years later, Bob awakes one morning to the sound of breaking glass. As he goes to the window to investigate, a huge branch, from a gigantic bush comes through the window,and smacks him in the face.
The bush was taller than the house, and blocked all light from the window. "What's this?!" exclaimed Bob "what happened to our cute litle bush?"

"I guess it grew. That just won't do." said Mary, defiantly "I'll just get someone here today to trim it back into our cute little bush!"

It doesn't work that way, Mary!

A man came to "trim" the bush. Mary showed it to him,and told him what she wanted. The man fell to his knees, and began to roll on the ground laughing. "Lady, thats a giant mutant ninja elaeagnus! Nobody plants those anywhere near a house! You want me to do what?! You've got to be kidding!!"

The moral of the story is: Don't buy a plant if you don't know what it is, and how big it will get!!!!(Read the Tag!)

The most common reason I end up digging up "mistakes" is, "I didn't know it would get that big!" Find out how big it gets before you plant it! It takes far more work to dig up your mistake than it did to plant it! READ THE TAG!

Trimming is not a substitute for poor design.
A shovel is often the best remedy. You can dig up
and rearrange your plants.


What does it matter....?

If you are going to shear whatever plant you get into squares, or watever unnatural shape, It doesn't make much difference what plant you use. Just as long as it matures at about the size you want. (and that won't matter for the first couple of years, and if you shear it enough, it won't live that long.) You might as well by the cheapest thing you can, as long as its green. For that matter, why not just put green plastic cubes in your yard. Then you won't have to trim them. Their natural shapes are what makes each plant unique. Why spend the money for a good plant if you are going to mutilate it beyond recognition? Why would you want something that grows if every time it puts out a new leaf, you run get the shears and cut it off? I've seen plants where you couldn't even find a whole leaf, they were all sheared in half. That's insane! It's also really ugly. Then, they can't figure out why their plants aren't healthy!!
Maybe I should go into the plastic cube business.

Photo: How many of what?
Photo: Squares and a Q-tip
Photo: Whatever they are, they're UGLY
Photo: Sheared beyond recognition
Monkey see, Monkey do
Next Page
Home