Edge of 17

Reviewed by: Benear

July 12, 1999

Return

Edge of Seventeen is a much better film than Get Real. It is also funnier. This film's teenager and his struggle with being gay was portrayed sympathetically without being sentimental. Or as sentimental I should say. There is still plenty of tugging at the heartstrings in this film.

Set in the mid-eighties, the film is a hoot in the costume department. The most fortunate thing for today's teens, gay and straight, is better fashions are available.

The message of sex for sex's sake and promiscuity as being damaging is problamatic. The protagonist fell in love at the drop of a hat then struggled with his pain when he discovered he was just being used for a good time. I think the problem is that he fell in love too quickly and thoughtlessly not that his partners were just out for a good time.

Finally, I just have one teeny tiny problem with the film. It is not possible to close a bar in Sandusky, drive to Columbus, loose your cherry and be back in Sandusky in time for breakfast. Other than that, I highly recommend this film. A great look at growing up gay in 1984. ...

And very realisticly portrayed with lots of shades of grey, unlike the black and white situation in Get Real. But I was a little bothered by what I interpreted as a denunciation of promiscuity. How else does one come to terms with that confusion unless one experiments?

Supposedly this film was more than a little autobiographical. I would submit that it is not common to meet someone in a bar, fall instantly in love and embark on a long lasting (monogamous?)relationship. Uncommon, but evidently not impossible.

It was one of the more erotic love scenes I have seen in awhile. And for a minute there, I thought it was going where no mainstream film has gone before. But that fade to black came just in a nick of time.

The rim job scene was hilarious. Something like that actually happened to me. I not only was unaware that people did such things, I was abruptly and verrrrry pleasantly surprised.