Isn't She Great?

Reviewed by: Cllrdr

January 25, 2000

Return

Well, no. Pretty good, but far from great. On paper it's a great idea: Bette Midler as Jacqueline Suzanne, with Nathan Lane as her hubby-manager Irving Mansfield, a Paul Rudnick script, and Andrew Bergman directing. Of course WILD "liberties" were taken with the truth. This is less the "real" Jackie Suzanne, than our collective imaginary memory of her filtered though 60's nostalgia and one too many viewings of VOTD. They even got Dionne Warwick to sing a title tune by Burt Bachrach and Hal David!

The "look" of it all is great, and scene for scene it's funny, but there's no narrative dynamic at work. Nathan is beautifully restrained. Bette has problems in the first part when she's trying to be a success (too shrill, no shading) but perfect when Jackie hits the jackpot (shrill as all hell, and who needs shading?) My colleague, Alonso Duralde, who's a big Suzanne-o-phile saw an early screening and didn't much like it: "It's kind of like Beaches with Bette playing both parts."

Still, it's worth seeing.