Smoke Signals

Reviewed by: Connie Mack

August 30, 1998

Return

Saw "Smoke Signals" last night. It was pretty darn good. Only slightly formulaic, and not self-pitying or self-aggrandizing at all.

Two Coeur d' Alene Indian young men -- Victor Joseph and Thomas Burns With Fire -- have grown up intertwined by an event which occurred when they were both infants. In 1976, there was a huge house party thrown on the rez, on the 4th of July, the White Man's Independence Day. In the middle of the night, a mysterious fire rages through the house, killing most within. Thomas' parents are trapped on the second floor and they fling the infant Thomas out the window. Victor's parents, watching the fire in disbelief and fear -- for they were originally in the house, but escaped -- are standing outside, Victor's mother holding the infant Victor. As the baby Thomas flies out the window, Victor's father runs across the yard and just barely catches Thomas in his outstretched hands. Thomas' grandmother runs up screaming, "What's happening? What's happened?" As the reality of the situation sinks in, she clutches the baby Thomas to her and informs Victor's father, "You saved my grandson's life", to which he replies, "I didn't mean to."

There's a lot of 'I didn't mean to' in this film. We fast forward to 1997, and back often to around 1988 or so, when the boys are 12. Victor grows up to be sullen, paranoid, inflamed, stoic. Thomas grows up becoming lyrical, comical, geeky, verbose and ever-pleasing. Victor can hardly bear to be around Thomas. And Thomas, who views Victor's dad as nearly his only father figure, adores Victor.

When the boys are 12, Victor's father leaves -- disappears. He'd been practicing disappearing via drinking and humor, but he finally just leaves. In the present, they receive word that Victor's father has died, down in Arizona. Thus we embark on a roadtrip, joining the mismatched duo on their trek to retrieve Victor's father and his pickup truck.

I won't go any farther in describing this movie, but you should see it. It has the requisite 'quirky' characters popping in and out, in many cases quite hilarious, and they're not necessarily foreseeable. There are enough surprises to keep you interested. It's shot in a lovely manner, paying homage to the beautiful West, both North and South. There's a beauty of movement and unfolding of landscape that are more like music than vision. The background music also is a lot of fun, with the expected and haunting "Indian" formations, but funny new twists on how "Indian" formation can be applied to songs you think you know.

Sometimes I found myself in awe of the cinematography; sometimes in awe of the dialogue. Thomas is a chronicler, this is his self- or otherwise-endowed 'gift'. He's our narrator, and Victor's conscience. Victor is complex, angry, proud, and slightly vain. He has deep feelings, but is ashamed to have them. Thomas feels no pain for having feelings, and is more 'in the moment' than Victor, or just about anyone else in the film.

Having lived in the West, both North and South, I recognized much in the way of accents (quite Canadian, up there, ay?) and attitudes. I've known Indians in both the Midwest and the West, and found in this movie a terrific representation of a droll, subsurface sense of humor. Humor is, in many cases, all rez Indians have for entertainment. It doesn't ask one to feel sorry for anyone, though, except as one human for another. We can, after all, be our own worst enemies, and the secrets we cleave unto ourselves can be more onerous and despicable than any judge or judgment.

It makes you think, this movie. It gives you a gorgeous panoramic view of the big Country we have out There. It has a tale to tell, of angers and hurts and what is regarded as known, and what is and forever more may remain unknown. It's a poem and a gift and a gratifying exploration.